How To Vet a Potential Employer Before Accepting an Offer

Laura • July 31, 2025

Plenty of people agree to an offer from a potential employer too fast, only to regret it soon after. Serious issues, such as toxic work culture and inadequate company leadership, can often be identified with proper vetting before it is too late. Before you sign anything, ask questions and do research, because your future depends on it.

As employment lawyers, we at S.T. Legal Group recommend doing due diligence and contacting us if anything seems off. The following is information our attorneys recommend on how to vet a potential employer before accepting an offer.

Look Past the Perks

The ping-pong table in the break room might look cool, but it is not a replacement for a healthy workplace culture. Perks are easy to flaunt. They are Instagrammable, but they are also the first thing to go when budgets tighten.

You need to ask, “Are these perks masking deeper issues, such as burnout or toxic management?” Arcade games and free snacks will not fix chronic micromanagement or unpaid overtime. Companies sometimes overcompensate with flashy benefits to distract from poor leadership or chaotic workflows.

At S.T. Legal Group, we advise clients to treat culture fit not as a buzzword but as a vital metric. If the potential employer talks more about free snacks or casual Fridays than mentorship or career growth, that is your cue to further evaluate their offer.

Ask the Right Questions in the Interview

You need to determine if an employer deserves your time, energy, and talent when you consider accepting an offer. Ask about how performance is measured, how conflict is handled, and why the role is open. A company that stumbles on those answers might be hiding problems behind a polished pitch.

Pay attention to hiring questions. Some things are illegal to ask and should be immediate deal-breakers. They cannot ask if you are pregnant, planning a family, what your religion is, or if you have a disability. The Illinois Human Rights Act protects job applicants from invasive or discriminatory questions. If you hear anything like this, not only should you make a polite escape, but you might consider reporting the incident.

You can file a complaint with the Illinois Department of Human Rights or with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Our employment lawyers have experience helping people who were asked illegal interview questions or passed over unfairly. Discrimination in hiring is against the law. Call us or email for clarification if you are ever unsure whether a question crossed the line.

Where and How To Research the Company

Before you accept a potential employer’s offer, screen them, and then look deeper. Start with Glassdoor and Indeed reviews and look for patterns. Are people mentioning the same issues, such as burnout or favoritism? A one-star rant might be bitterness, while five-star love letters might be planted. The truth usually lives somewhere in between. While three and a half to four stars out of five might seem low compared to Google or Yelp reviews, that is a fairly standard Glassdoor or Indeed rating.

Search LinkedIn and Reddit for unfiltered takes. Likewise, searching the executives on social media might provide context and clarification. Leadership style shows up in more than just memos. Additionally, some green flags on the company’s own social media pages are employees chiming in and the company responding to both positive and negative comments. On the other hand, it is telling if the company has turned off comments. What a company allows or deletes says a lot about its tolerance for transparency.

Check the company’s Better Business Bureau listing as well. As employment lawyers, we also suggest googling the company name with keywords such as “lawsuit,” “scandal,” or “settlement.”

What Are Your Legal Rights Before Signing?

Before you accept the job offer, review everything from your potential employer. Some companies slip in noncompete clauses, mandatory arbitration agreements, or vague confidentiality language that can have consequences for you.

If something feels like a red flag in your offer letter or employment contract, it can be a legal gray area or worse. Pay attention to what is written about severance, notice periods, intellectual property, and restrictive covenants. If the company suddenly gets evasive when you ask for clarification, it might be time to have a lawyer review your contract before signing.

Call Our Attorneys For Help Reviewing a New Job Offer

S.T. Legal Group has seen people stuck in a legal predicament in their new job because they did not fully understand what they were signing. Always have a good idea of how to vet a potential employer before accepting an offer.

When in doubt, get an employer or contract vetted by an employment attorney. To get started, contact us now to set up an appointment.

Person using laptop at a desk with books, a phone, and framed photos.
By Laura July 31, 2025
As employment lawyers, we want you to fully appreciate that job interviews are not a forum for personal questions.
Woman with head in hands at a desk with laptop, notebook, phone, and glasses; appearing stressed.
By Laura July 10, 2025
Losing your job can be incredibly stressful, especially if you believe the reason you were let go was for an unfair reason.
Man in blazer, pants, and white shirt, holding a bag and books, standing on a road.
By Laura July 10, 2025
If you recently lost your job through no fault of your own, you may want to consider filing a wrongful termination suit.
Four people in a meeting: one shakes hands with another, three sit at a table with laptops and documents.
By Laura July 10, 2025
Knowing the specifics of non-compete agreements typically takes time and experience.
Open notebook with a pen, surrounded by paper question marks in beige and white tones.
July 10, 2025
Job searching or starting a new job comes with a unique set of challenges. You want to present yourself well during your interview and the first few weeks at work.
Woman working on a laptop at a desk, surrounded by plants and office supplies.
By David Brenton July 3, 2024
As we all wend our way through this difficult period, employment issues and disputes arise for both employers and their employees in a number of fields, especially in the pharmaceutical industry.
Two people in suits shaking hands at a desk with legal scales, documents, and a gavel.
By David Brenton July 3, 2024
S.T. Legal Group, an accomplished employment law practice, provides valuable counsel and strong representation to employers and employees throughout Lake County, Illinois.
Person writing on a clipboard across from another person at a table with a laptop, documents, and a pen.
By stlegalgroup April 7, 2024
What Are the Legal Implications of Non-Compete Agreements? Non-compete agreements are a form of restrictive covenant for employment in Illinois. \
Three men collaborating around a laptop on a white table in an office. Colorful geometric floor design.
By stlegalgroup March 11, 2024
Unfair dismissal, also known as wrongful termination, refers to an unfortunate situation wherein an employee is fired by their employer for reasons that appear unauthorized or against state law.
Man with glasses holds paperwork, looking stressed, hand on head.
By stlegalgroup February 5, 2024
Illinois workers are protected by both state and federal laws.